present. we talked to members of the staff. we talked to a number of city department leaders, and their staff. we talked to a number of grantees of the arts commission, street artists, a nonprofit executives, journalists, we reviewed the city charter, the police code, ordinances, the commission's bylaws, their minutes, budgets, website, publications, orientation package for new commissioners, artists, sunshine materials, just to give you an idea that we really took this thing very seriously, and went to a lot of effort to sort of gain a clear understanding of what the arts commission's situation is about. in recent times, the president of the arts commission resigned, and was replaced by the mayor. the director of cultural affairs resigned and was replaced. the deputy director position was reinstated and was refilled.